By punishing them from the beginning or earlier in the game without having a taste of enjoyment you could easily lose them. Loyal addicted players all start as free players that had a good time with the game. I believe it is better to sacrifice BG withdrawal value in half (make it 200=1$) but make the game twice as fast and enjoyable.
It would be nice to make my lands a bit more interactive. A chat would be a good feature in addition to messages. Players are very social, they love to interact with other players. this adds to players enjoyment of the game. Its also a good venue to meet new like minded people and make new friends. It would be another good reason why they would play this game.
world chat= chat with everyone online across the empire and servers,
Faction chat= chat with online members of the same faction
Clan chat = chat with online clan members
alliance chat= chat with you allies
Private chat= one on one chat with a player
What do you think people?

Do you like my suggestion?
